Etienne Urbah on 2010-03-17

• Propose requirement with title  'All grid entities MUST be described using the GLUE model'

Etienne Urbah's position on 2010-04-13

• OGF has designed the GLUE model as a description of grid entities which is uniform across grids, permitting to pass references of grid entities across grid boundaries
• Since the GLUE model is (or will shortly be) implemented by major grids, all new OGF recommendations MUST manage or reference only grid entities compatible with the GLUE model, SHOULD stick to entity attributes defined inside the GLUE model and SHOULD make the best usage of them
• I consider the GLUE model as the foundation of interoperability, therefore I vote FOR this requirement

Morris, Balazs and Etienne on 2010-04-21

• Source = GIN
• Add 'most recent' to the original title
• That permits to label requirement IS1.1 as duplicate of this requirement
• Spreadsheet ID = 1

Etienne Urbah's addition on 2010-04-21

• Following is copied from detail page of duplicate requirement IS1.1 :
• Since the latest published GLUE recommendation (currently GLUE 2.0) is (or will shortly be) implemented by major grids, all useful OGF recommendations MUST manage or reference only grid entities compatible with it, SHOULD stick to its entity attributes and SHOULD make the best usage of them :
  - All new OGF recommendations MUST be designed in this way
  - Useful old OGF recommendations (such as BES, JSDL, ...) MUST to be corrected in this way
• For example, JSDL currently describes the Operating System with 'OperatingSystemType' and 'OperatingSystemName', but will have to use 'OSFamily' and 'OSName' instead
• Each time the GLUE model will be revised, all useful old OGF recommendations SHOULD also be revised in order to take the new GLUE model into account
• I confirm my vote FOR this requirement

Amsterdam meeting on 2010-04-29

• Change title to  'All grid entities (if possible) MUST be described using the GLUE model.  If not possible, extensions for the GLUE model are necessary'
• That permits to label requirement IS1.2 as duplicate of this requirement
• Open  (clear, but NO agreement by Andrew)

Chicago meeting on 2010-06-22

• Mark MORGAN: We first need a standard defining the XML rendering of GLUE
• General agreement that publication of this standard defining XML rendering of GLUE would permit to agree on this requirement
• Agreed YES