This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/sfmain/do/go/artf3403?nav=1&selectedTab=comments at Sun, 06 Nov 2022 08:40:57 GMT SourceForge : artf3403: (1491) CDDLM Configuration Description Language (CDL) Spec

Project Home

Tracker

Documents

Tasks

Source Code

Discussions

File Releases

Wiki

Project Admin
Search Tracker
Project: Editor     Trackers > Published > View Artifact
Artifact artf3403 : (1491) CDDLM Configuration Description Language (CDL) Spec
Tracker: Published
Title: (1491) CDDLM Configuration Description Language (CDL) Spec
Description:
This is the third CDDLM Spec, this one describing XML-based Configuration Description Language. It is a follow-up to 
SmartFrog language spec..
Submitted By: dejan@hpl.hp.com
Submitted On: 06/01/2005 10:13 AM EST
Last Modified: 05/06/2007 4:46 AM EDT
Closed: 01/18/2007 2:33 PM EST

Status / Comments Change Log Associations Attachments (7)  
Status  
Group: * APME
Status:* Closed
Category: * Community Practice
Customer: *
Priority: * 0
Assigned To: * None
Reported in Release: *
Fixed in Release: *
Estimated Hours: * 0
Actual Hours: * 0
resolution: *
Comments
Greg Newby: 05/06/2007 4:46 AM EDT
  Action: Update
resolution changed from Accepted to none (no value)
Greg Newby: 01/18/2007 2:33 PM EST
  Action: Move
Moved from Submit OGF Draft to Published
Category changed from Recommendations Track to Community Practice
Group changed from Management to APME
resolution set to Accepted
Greg Newby: 01/18/2007 2:33 PM EST
  Comment:
Published.
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to none (no value)
Closed set to 01/18/2007
Priority changed from 1 to 0
Status changed from Ready to Publish to Closed
Greg Newby: 01/08/2007 3:10 PM EST
  Comment:
This will now be published as GFD-RP.085.  Thanks to the authors/editors for efforts on this document.
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 2 to 1
Status changed from GFSG Review: Last call to Ready to Publish
Greg Newby: 12/08/2006 11:53 PM EST
  Action: Update
Status changed from GFSG Review: 15-day final to GFSG Review: Last call
Greg Newby: 12/08/2006 11:40 PM EST
  Comment:
The standards council approved this document.  It is now in last call on the GFSG mailing list, prior to publication.
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Ellen Stokes to Greg Newby
Greg Newby: 11/26/2006 9:02 PM EST
  Action: Update
Assigned To set to Ellen Stokes
Greg Newby: 11/26/2006 8:46 PM EST
  Comment:
Attached file received via email from P. Toft.  This document will now go to 15-day final GFSG review.
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl.doc (485.5 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Status changed from Returned to Author(s) to Final 15day GFSG Review
Greg Newby: 09/03/2006 8:03 PM EDT
  Comment:
Sent a ping to the submitter.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 06/27/2006 11:34 AM EDT
  Action: Update
Status changed from Pending Info from Authors to Returned to Author(s)
Hiro Kishimoto: 05/27/2006 11:09 PM EDT
  Comment:
I am sorry to be late but the attached is markup file with my comments. I hope author will take care of these comments before GFD publication.
  Action: Update
Hiro Kishimoto: 05/27/2006 11:09 PM EDT
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-002-hiro.pdf (663.47 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 867: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-002-hiro.pdf
Greg Newby: 05/26/2006 1:38 PM EDT
  Comment:
Public comment is now complete. Authors/editors, please review comments
and post here (and set the tracker back to gbn) when you
are ready to move forward.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 05/26/2006 1:38 PM EDT
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Public Comment Period to Pending Info from Authors
assigned_to changed from 9357 to 628
Priority changed from 3 to 2
Greg Newby: 03/26/2006 7:14 PM EST
  Comment:
Announced March 26.  The link to public comments:
https://forge.gridforum.org/forum/forum.php?forum_id=599

Sorry for the delay in getting this on the comment page
and announced.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 02/12/2006 2:39 AM EST
  Comment:
This will now enter 60-day public comment (most
likely after GGF16 ends), with comments due
60 days after announcement.

Authors/editors, please encourage WG members,
affiliates and others to provide public comments.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 02/12/2006 2:39 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Returned to Author(s) to Public Comment Period
assigned_to changed from 628 to 9357
Priority changed from 4 to 3
resolution changed from Returned to Authors/Group to <None>
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 02/07/2006 5:55 PM EST
  Comment:
Dejan accepted all changes
  Action: Update
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 02/07/2006 5:55 PM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-002.doc (346.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 733: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-002.doc
Hiro Kishimoto: 01/30/2006 11:03 PM EST
  Comment:
Revised draft for GGF Editor submission. My comments dated 2005-08-09 are resolved and CDDLM-WG has agreed that this draft satisfies the SmartFrog 
compatibility issues.
  Action: Update
Hiro Kishimoto: 01/30/2006 11:03 PM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-001.doc (448 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 732: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl2-001.doc
Greg Newby: 09/25/2005 5:20 PM EST
  Comment:
Emailed Dejan to remind him of this document's
status (awaiting some changes prior to public
comment) September 25.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/06/2005 10:58 AM EST
  Comment:
(Updated priority category & Assigned To for accuracy)
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/06/2005 10:58 AM EST
  Action: Update
assigned_to changed from 302 to 628
Priority changed from 2 to 4
Greg Newby: 08/09/2005 9:58 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_group changed from old-SRM to Management
artifact_status changed from GFSG Review to Returned to Author(s)
Priority changed from 4 to 2
resolution changed from Works For Me to Returned to Authors/Group
Greg Newby: 08/09/2005 9:48 AM EST
  Comment:
The GFSG would like to see this renamed more consistently
with the "CDDLM SmartFrog-Based Language Specification,"
as well as the other comments in the tracker -- notably those
from Hiro, as well as John's comments about formatting.

Authors, would you please create a new version of this
document based on this GFSG feedback, and submit
it to the tracker?  At that time, we'll go ahead with another
GFSG review (though it might be faster than the full
15 days).  Thanks!
  Action: Update
Hiro Kishimoto: 08/09/2005 2:06 AM EST
  Comment:
I read XML-CDL document and find a lot of nits. See attached file. However most of them are for readability and there is no showstopper. I think it is
 ok to start public comment period.
  Action: Update
Hiro Kishimoto: 08/09/2005 2:06 AM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-12-hiro.doc (376 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 664: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-12-hiro.doc
None: 08/08/2005 9:36 PM EST
  Comment:
I see quite a bit of use of "should"  and "should not", eg, "The configuration description should be declarative: it should not be a sequence of 
operations...". These references however are not using the notational conventions "SHOULD" or "SHOULD NOT" (to be clear, you do have these notational 
conventions also). Perhaps your use of the non-convention form accurately conveys your intention, but it may warrant a review. 

Copyright date should be changed from (date) to 2005.

I recommend this document proceed.

Thanks!
John Tollefsrud
  Action: Update
David Snelling: 07/26/2005 10:03 AM EST
  Comment:
Following Greg's request move to GSFG review
  Action: Update
David Snelling: 07/26/2005 10:03 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Initial Editor Review to GFSG Review
Priority changed from 5 to 4
Greg Newby: 07/19/2005 4:52 AM EST
  Comment:
Thanks for these changes.  I will schedule this for 15-day GFSG
review.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 07/19/2005 4:52 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Returned to Author(s) to Initial Editor Review
assigned_to changed from 133 to 302
Priority changed from 4 to 5
resolution changed from Returned to Authors/Group to Works For Me
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 07/14/2005 9:26 AM EST
  Comment:
Dejan has resubmitted the document with requested changes (IP moved back, changes acceted, and TOC recreated)

Question: should it be assigned to Bill Nitzberg or to Greg Newby?
  Action: Update
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 07/14/2005 9:26 AM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-12.doc (376 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 648: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-12.doc
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 07/14/2005 9:25 AM EST
  Comment:
Dejan has resubmitted the document with requested changes (IP moved back, changes acceted, and TOC recreated)

Question: should it be assigned to Bill Nitzberg or to Greg Newby?
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 06/26/2005 1:47 PM EST
  Comment:
Thanks for this submission, which I have now read.  Before
presenting this to the GFSG for a 15-day review, I would
like a document with improved formatting.

Authors/editors, would you please re-submit this document with:
- all "changes" accepted in MS Word
- the copyright statement (without the GGF logo) similar to any
recently published GGF document and GFD-C.1
- regenerated/current table of contents

I did not see any problems with this document, but will take
another look before sending it for GFSG 15-day review.  After
the review will be a 60 day public comment period.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 06/26/2005 1:47 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Initial Editor Review to Returned to Author(s)
assigned_to changed from 302 to 133
Priority changed from 5 to 4
resolution changed from <None> to Returned to Authors/Group
Greg Newby: 06/19/2005 9:01 PM EST
  Comment:
This document is in initial editor review, and I'll get
back to you shortly with the next steps.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 06/19/2005 9:01 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Open to Initial Editor Review
Priority changed from - to 5
dejan@hpl.hp.com: 06/01/2005 10:13 AM EST
  Action: Create

dejan@hpl.hp.com: 06/01/2005 10:13 AM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-11.doc (569.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 622: draft-ggf-cddlm-xml-cdl-11.doc

 
 
 
< Previous
 
 
Next >
 


The Open Grid Forum Contact Webmaster | Report a problem | GridForge Help
This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/sfmain/do/go/artf3403?nav=1&selectedTab=comments at Sun, 06 Nov 2022 08:40:57 GMT