Dieter, Shailendra, Cecile, Abdeslem, Chris (minutes)

apologies: Susan, Steve F

+ We believe that action 27 should just be pushed to action 17.

+ Went over chris' list from May F2F for names/dates:

Agree and circulate terminology: publication, publication description,
publication pre-processing, consumption, artifacts, entities.
    - Dieter, John, Cecile
    + completed as of Chicago

Circulate new Use Case Template
    - Steve F.
    + complete

Circulate R-GMA Network Monitoring Use Case Notes (Overview, Attributes of
objects in the registry, Steps, What changes in the registry at each step)
    - Steve F.
    + partially complete?

First draft of Nextgrid Animation Use Case
    - Stephen Davey
    + complete

Clean up specification
    - Cecile
    + already entered for 4. August

Produce interaction diagram to guide readers in understanding general usage
    - Chris
    + need spec/api to settle

Write up consumer service requirement - is this addressed by POBOX?
    - Steve F.

Create INFOD patterns based on Cecile's document for INFOD F2F at Abingdon -
    - Steve F. and Susan
        + superceded

Investigate if  implementing (1) Getdata (2) Consume/Receive (3) Subscribe
(Create Consumer) on an entity is the same as an R-GMA Consumer Service.
    - Abdeslem
        + superceded by POBOX

Investigate how WSN Pull Point relates to R-GMA Consumer Service
    - Abdeslem
        + superceded by POBOX

Review Consumptions (e.g., preprocessing of messages prior to receipt, shared
consumptions)
    - Dieter, Shailendra, Cecile
        + 11. August 2005, possible dupe?

Add pattern of many publishers publishing using the same PublicationType via association
    - Cecile
        + may just explain this in the spec

Review separation of data retention from data publishing
    - Cecile and Dieter
        + 11. August, possible dupe?

WSN Summary Review
    - Susan and Abdeslem
        + 11. August at latest?

Define late binding and determine where late binding is supported
    - Shailendra
        - expanding recipient list from logical EPR?
        + 11. August

Define Non-events - are they are deadline related?
    - Cecile and Dieter
        + 4. August

Define INFOD Factoring
    - Cecile
        + 4. August

Issues (with some actions):

What's the difference between a disseminator and a WSN broker? publication and
WSN topic?  Vocabulary and WSN filter?
Can WSN send message directly to a consumer by name?
        - Abdeslem and Susan, part of WSN review

Should Vocabulary Management and Identity Management be part of the specification?
        - no, see email from Dieter on 20. July

Publications are defined by topics in WSN, how does that differ from INFOD
mechanisms for controlling publications through vocabularies?
       * Review what's in the specification on vocabularies and give feedback -
         Steve Fisher
       * Review what's in the specification about disseminators and give feedback
       - Abdeslem and Susan, part of WSN review

Do disseminators provide transforms?
       - Shailendra and Dieter
       * may require/desire some specific patterns to show how this is usable
         as a queueing system, to be done after current rewrite (4. Aug)

What's special about INFOD disseminators?         e.g.,
         Retention of information
         Querying information
         Auditing and tracking
       * open until after current rewrite (4. Aug)

+ Steve's item deferred to next week (28. Jul). item 27 doesn't make sense
let's just give item 17 to Steve F.

+ We agreed that Abdeslem's writeup (http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/07/msg00016.html) clears 
up issue 1.
Needs to be moved to the issues doc, along with the relevant Chicago
F2F excerpt (http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/07/msg00017.html), from Cecile.

+ We spent some time trying to understand Dieter's writeup for issue 7
(http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/07/msg00013.html).
The...