SourceForge : artf6440: SMOA Computing HPC Basic Profile adoption

Project: Editor Trackers > Published > View Artifact

Artifact artf6440 : SMOA Computing HPC Basic Profile adoption – Experience Report

Tracker:	Published
Title:	SMOA Computing HPC Basic Profile adoption – Experience Report
Description:	This document describe experience gained while implementing the SMOA Computing Service [1], a component which development was steered by the following OGF specifications: • GFD 108 - OGSA® Basic Execution Service Version 1.0 [2] • GFD.114 - HPC Basic Profile, Version 1.0 [3] • GFD.135 - HPC File Staging Profile, Version 1.0 [4] In addition to comments on those specifications, this document presents possible extension to the Basic Execution Service: a separate interface for managing Advance Reservations based on the BES-Factory port.
Submitted By:	Michal Kulczewski
Submitted On:	03/12/2010 10:51 AM EST
Last Modified:	03/19/2011 11:46 PM EDT

	Status / Comments		Change Log		Associations		Attachments (5)

Status
Group: *
Status:*	Closed
Category: *	Experimental
Customer: *
Priority: *	1
Assigned To: *	Joel Replogle
Reported in Release: *
Fixed in Release: *
Estimated Hours: *	0
Actual Hours: *	0
resolution: *	Accepted

Comments

Greg Newby: 03/19/2011 11:46 PM EDT
	Action:	Move Moved from Submit OGF Draft to Published Group changed from Individual Submission to none (no value) resolution set to Accepted Status changed from Ready to Publish to Closed

Joel Replogle: 03/19/2011 10:42 PM EDT
	Comment:	Published as GFD-E.179 on 2011-03-20. http://www.ogf.org/documents/GFD.179.pdf
	Action:	Update

Greg Newby: 02/07/2011 1:54 PM EST
	Comment:	All's well. This will now be published as GFD-E.179. Thanks to the authors/editors work work on this document.
	Action:	Update Assigned To changed from Andrew Grimshaw to Joel Replogle Priority changed from 2 to 1 Status changed from GFSG Review: 15-day final to Ready to Publish

Greg Newby: 02/07/2011 12:28 PM EST
	Comment:	This was discussed during the February 5 telecon. Alan Sill will check with Andrew Grimshaw concerning readiness to publish, otherwise the standards council is ready for this to be published.
	Action:	Update

Greg Newby: 01/24/2011 1:04 PM EST
	Action:	Update Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Andrew Grimshaw

Michal Kulczewski: 01/20/2011 3:57 AM EST
	Comment:	Editable version attached.
	Attachment:	BES-Experience-Report-after-comments.docx (156.97 KB)
	Action:	Update Added an attachment.

Greg Newby: 01/19/2011 6:24 PM EST

Comment:

Thanks.  This is now headed for final standards council review, for discussion on about February 14 as scheduling allows.
Note that we will need the editable source of the document, in this tracker.  Thanks again.

Action:

Update
Priority changed from 4 to 2
Status changed from Author Action Needed to GFSG Review: 15-day final

Michal Kulczewski: 01/04/2011 8:54 AM EST
	Comment:	New version reflecting Andrew's comments.
	Attachment:	BES-Experience-Report-after-comments.pdf (247.94 KB)
	Action:	Update Added an attachment.

Greg Newby: 11/22/2010 11:27 AM EST
	Comment:	Update from OGF meeting: Andre will talk with the author about how to get community buy-in
	Action:	Update

Greg Newby: 10/24/2010 9:22 AM EDT
	Comment:	The standards council will discuss this at OGF.
	Action:	Update

Greg Newby: 09/27/2010 4:51 PM EDT
	Action:	Update Assigned To set to Greg Newby

Greg Newby: 09/21/2010 10:40 AM EDT
	Comment:	Thanks for your comments, Andrew. The standards council will discuss this document further during an upcoming telecon.
	Action:	Update

Andrew Grimshaw: 09/21/2010 9:31 AM EDT
	Comment:	See comments in PDF
	Attachment:	HPCBP-Experience-Report-asg.pdf (212.37 KB)
	Action:	Update Added an attachment.

Greg Newby: 08/24/2010 10:47 AM EDT

Comment:

I've asked the standards council how to proceed with this.  Zero public comments is not reflective of an engaged community process, and there is no 
affirmation that the experiences in the document are reflective of reality.

Action:

Update
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to none (no value)
Priority changed from 3 to 4
Status changed from Public Comment Period to Author Action Needed

Joel Replogle: 05/06/2010 10:07 AM EDT
	Comment:	Re-entered 30-day Public Comment on 2010-05-06. Comment URL: http://www.ogf.org/gf/docs/comment.php?id=332
	Action:	Update

Greg Newby: 05/01/2010 6:58 PM EDT

Comment:

Michal, others: there were no public comments (other than some unfortunate spam).  This is not indicative of community support from the (many) people 
involved in the related specs and experiences.

We will send this for another 30-day public comment period.  During that time, please solicit the constituents to affirm they have read this document 
and it is representative of BES experiences.

Thanks in advance for your efforts to demonstrate community support for this important document.

Action:

Update

Joel Replogle: 03/23/2010 12:12 PM EDT
	Comment:	Entered 30-day Public Comment on 2010-03-23. Comment URL: http://www.ogf.org/gf/docs/comment.php?id=332
	Action:	Update

Michal Kulczewski: 03/17/2010 4:15 AM EDT
	Comment:	Footer corected, and editable version uploaded.
	Attachment:	BES-Experience-Report.docx (152.42 KB)
	Action:	Update Added an attachment.

Greg Newby: 03/15/2010 2:50 PM EDT

Comment:

Thanks for this.  Please also upload an editable version of the document.

Other than the wrong footer (editor@), this looks good and is ready for 30 day public comment. Once it is available for comment, please solicit people
 from the groups upon which you based your experience document (i.e., OGSA and others) for comments.  

Thanks again for your submission.

Action:

Update
Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 4 to 3
resolution changed from Accepted to none (no value)
Status changed from AD Review to Public Comment Period

Michal Kulczewski: 03/12/2010 10:51 AM EST
	Attachment:	HPCBP-Experience-Report.pdf (197.66 KB)
	Action:	Create Added an attachment.

Return

< Previous

Next >