This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/tracker/do/viewArtifact/projects.ogsa-wg/tracker.ogsa_architecture/artf6087?nav=1&selectedTab=history at Sun, 06 Nov 2022 22:04:56 GMT SourceForge : artf6087: Consider use of terms "entity" & "identity"

Project Home

Tracker

Documents

Tasks

Source Code

Discussions

File Releases

Wiki

Project Admin

Glance

Calendar
Search Tracker
Project: OGSA-WG     Trackers > OGSA Architecture > View Artifact
Artifact artf6087 : Consider use of terms "entity" & "identity"
Tracker: OGSA Architecture
Title: Consider use of terms "entity" & "identity"
Description:
In public comments for the OGSA Glossary v1.6, Allen Luniewski made the following comment regarding entity and identity.
  On the OGSA telecon of November 19, 2007 we decided that this should be submitted as a tracker to be considered as an 
update in the next revision of the Architecture document, and that the Glossary definitions should then be updated to 
reflect any changes made.

Allen's comments:

Entity/Identity.  An entity is defined as "Any nameable thing."  This implies that to be an entity in the OGSA 
environment the thing must have a name.  Since the definition of "name" is very general (especially the "address" 
component of it), it is hard to say that this is wrong.  but it certainly is a bit misleading.  When one looks at the 
definition of identity ("An attribute, such as a name, that allows one entity to be distinguished from all others.".  
This seems to reinforce the point by implying that an entity only needs to have an identity and that the identity might 
be something other than a name.

** Additional comment from Allen in e-mail to Jem 11/29/2007: My off the cuff solution would be to change the definition
 of entity to read "Any uniquely identifiable thing." The idea is that an entity is a thing that can be denoted in some 
manner that gets one precisely to that thing.

** Additional comment from Donal Fellows 12/6/200, also commenting on the Glossary 1.6: Entity - should mention that 
entities may have state.
Submitted By: Jem Treadwell
Submitted On: 11/29/2007 2:19 PM EST
Last Modified: 12/06/2007 11:08 PM EST

Status / Comments Change Log Associations Attachments  
 (2 Items)
Field Old Value New Value Date Performed By
Description
In public comments for the OGSA Glossary v1.6, Allen Luniewski made the 
following comment regarding entity and identity.  On the OGSA telecon of 
November 19, 2007 we decided that this should be submitted as a tracker to be 
considered as an update in the next revision of the Architecture document, and 
that the Glossary definitions should then be updated to reflect any changes made
.

Allen's comments:

Entity/Identity.  An entity is defined as "Any nameable thing."  This implies 
that to be an entity in the OGSA environment the thing must have a name.  Since 
the definition of "name" is very general (especially the "address" component of 
it), it is hard to say that this is wrong.  but it certainly is a bit misleading
.  When one looks at the definition of identity ("An attribute, such as a name, 
that allows one entity to be distinguished from all others.".  This seems to 
reinforce the point by implying that an entity only needs to have an identity 
and that the identity might be something other than a name.

** Additional comment from Allen in e-mail to Jem 11/29/2007: My off the cuff 
solution would be to change the definition of entity to read "Any uniquely 
identifiable thing." The idea is that an entity is a thing that can be denoted 
in some manner that gets one precisely to that thing.
In public comments for the OGSA Glossary v1.6, Allen Luniewski made the 
following comment regarding entity and identity.  On the OGSA telecon of 
November 19, 2007 we decided that this should be submitted as a tracker to be 
considered as an update in the next revision of the Architecture document, and 
that the Glossary definitions should then be updated to reflect any changes made
.

Allen's comments:

Entity/Identity.  An entity is defined as "Any nameable thing."  This implies 
that to be an entity in the OGSA environment the thing must have a name.  Since 
the definition of "name" is very general (especially the "address" component of 
it), it is hard to say that this is wrong.  but it certainly is a bit misleading
.  When one looks at the definition of identity ("An attribute, such as a name, 
that allows one entity to be distinguished from all others.".  This seems to 
reinforce the point by implying that an entity only needs to have an identity 
and that the identity might be something other than a name.

** Additional comment from Allen in e-mail to Jem 11/29/2007: My off the cuff 
solution would be to change the definition of entity to read "Any uniquely 
identifiable thing." The idea is that an entity is a thing that can be denoted 
in some manner that gets one precisely to that thing.

** Additional comment from Donal Fellows 12/6/200, also commenting on the 
Glossary 1.6: Entity - should mention that entities may have state.
12/06/2007 11:08 PM EST Jem Treadwell
Description
In public comments for the OGSA Glossary v1.6, Allen Luniewski made the 
following comment regarding entity and identity.  On the OGSA telecon of 
November 19, 2007 we decided that this should be submitted as a tracker to be 
considered as an update in the next revision of the Architecture document, and 
that the Glossary definitions should then be updated to reflect any changes made
.

Allen's comments:

Entity/Identity.  An entity is defined as "Any nameable thing."  This implies 
that to be an entity in the OGSA environment the thing must have a name.  Since 
the definition of "name" is very general (especially the "address" component of 
it), it is hard to say that this is wrong.  but it certainly is a bit misleading
.  When one looks at the definition of identity ("An attribute, such as a name, 
that allows one entity to be distinguished from all others.".  This seems to 
reinforce the point by implying that an entity only needs to have an identity 
and that the identity might be something other than a name.
In public comments for the OGSA Glossary v1.6, Allen Luniewski made the 
following comment regarding entity and identity.  On the OGSA telecon of 
November 19, 2007 we decided that this should be submitted as a tracker to be 
considered as an update in the next revision of the Architecture document, and 
that the Glossary definitions should then be updated to reflect any changes made
.

Allen's comments:

Entity/Identity.  An entity is defined as "Any nameable thing."  This implies 
that to be an entity in the OGSA environment the thing must have a name.  Since 
the definition of "name" is very general (especially the "address" component of 
it), it is hard to say that this is wrong.  but it certainly is a bit misleading
.  When one looks at the definition of identity ("An attribute, such as a name, 
that allows one entity to be distinguished from all others.".  This seems to 
reinforce the point by implying that an entity only needs to have an identity 
and that the identity might be something other than a name.

** Additional comment from Allen in e-mail to Jem 11/29/2007: My off the cuff 
solution would be to change the definition of entity to read "Any uniquely 
identifiable thing." The idea is that an entity is a thing that can be denoted 
in some manner that gets one precisely to that thing.
12/03/2007 9:37 PM EST Jem Treadwell

 
 
 
Next >
 


The Open Grid Forum Contact Webmaster | Report a problem | GridForge Help
This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/tracker/do/viewArtifact/projects.ogsa-wg/tracker.ogsa_architecture/artf6087?nav=1&selectedTab=history at Sun, 06 Nov 2022 22:04:57 GMT