|
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/21/2009 8:27 PM EST
|
|
Comment: |
Slightly updated documents received.
a) PDF file, ready to be uploaded as a GFD-I. 145.
b) word file for the main part of document
c) Excel file for the appendix of table
|
|
Attachment: |
application_of_guideline_20090215_2.xls
(55.5 KB)
|
|
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
resolution changed from Accepted to none (no value)
Status changed from Closed to Ready to Publish
|
|
|
|
Joel Replogle: 02/14/2009 11:18 PM EST
|
|
Comment: |
Published as GFD.145 on 2009-02-14.
|
|
Action: |
Update
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/04/2009 8:28 PM EST
|
|
Comment: |
Per email with the author, the 10/30/2008 file is ready for publication as GFD-I.145.
Thanks to the contributors for this successful document!
|
|
Action: |
Update
Priority changed from 3 to 1
Status changed from Public Comment Period to Ready to Publish
|
|
Joel Replogle: 11/19/2008 12:30 PM EST
|
|
Comment: |
Entered Public comment 2008-11-19.
|
|
Action: |
Update
|
|
Greg Newby: 11/01/2008 4:34 PM EDT
|
|
Comment: |
Thanks. This will now go for 30-day public comment.
Please solicit interested persons to submit comments, which are an excellent indicator of community involvement with the document's topic.
|
|
Action: |
Update
Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 4 to 3
Status changed from Author Action Needed to Public Comment Period
|
|
Satoshi Itoh: 10/30/2008 9:17 PM EDT
|
|
Comment: |
I have modified the document according to your comment.
The modified document is uploaded by the format of word in the forge.
following is how i modified the document.
> There are a few items that should be attended to, before this can be submitted for public comment. Please let me know if you have any questions,
concerns, or uncertainty about how to proceed.
>
> - remove line numbers
I did.
> - the Contributors section needs to include full contact information for all contributors (authors/editors), and identify a corresponding author.
Please see the sample document in the GridForge Editor area, or look at any recently published document, for an example
I added author information.
Corresponding auther, me, only has e-mail address.
> - The first section of the Appendix has some unusual line breaks and capitalization. Please check this and update as needed. Particularly lines
277-282.
The first line with asterisk means name of category and the second line
without asterisk means name of actual use case. If the use case include
name of company or project, it has capital.
So, line breaks have meaning. But I changed it by using indentation.
> I suggest also updating some of the formatting. There are many cases in section 4.1 and the Appendix where there is an asterisk in the leftmost
column, then an indentation, then a bullet or list number (such as a, b, c). Consider dropping the asterisk, and instead insure consistent
indentation and numbering/bulleting (see also section 1.1, which is not indented like the other list items). Consistency will make the document
easier to read.
Delete astarisk and use a) etc. and no indentation for all items.
|
|
Attachment: |
requirement-guideline-20081031.doc
(118.5 KB)
|
|
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
Greg Newby: 10/30/2008 2:49 PM EDT
|
|
Comment: |
I heard from the submitted that this document will be updated and resubmitted soon.
|
|
Action: |
Update
|
|
Greg Newby: 10/10/2008 4:02 PM EDT
|
|
Comment: |
Sent a ping to the submitter.
|
|
Action: |
Update
|
|
Greg Newby: 09/27/2008 3:13 PM EDT
|
|
Action: |
Update
Group changed from Industry Applications to Enterprise areas
|
|
Greg Newby: 09/27/2008 2:56 PM EDT
|
|
Comment: |
Thanks for this submission. We also need to get an editable (.doc or similar) file for this.
There are a few items that should be attended to, before this can be submitted for public comment. Please let me know if you have any questions,
concerns, or uncertainty about how to proceed.
- remove line numbers
- the Contributors section needs to include full contact information for all contributors (authors/editors), and identify a corresponding author.
Please see the sample document in the GridForge Editor area, or look at any recently published document, for an example
- The first section of the Appendix has some unusual line breaks and capitalization. Please check this and update as needed. Particularly lines 277-
282.
I suggest also updating some of the formatting. There are many cases in section 4.1 and the Appendix where there is an asterisk in the leftmost
column, then an indentation, then a bullet or list number (such as a, b, c). Consider dropping the asterisk, and instead insure consistent
indentation and numbering/bulleting (see also section 1.1, which is not indented like the other list items). Consistency will make the document
easier to read.
Once you've tended to the above, please re-submit the editable version and we'll move it to public comment. Thanks again for this submission. The
above comments/suggestions are largely for formatting etc. The content, overall, looks ready for widespread distribution and comment.
|
|
Action: |
Update
Priority changed from 3 to 4
Status changed from AD Review to Author Action Needed
|
|
|
|