|
|
|
Greg Newby: 04/29/2008 11:02 AM EDT
|
| |
Action: |
Move
Moved from Submit OGF Draft to Published
Group changed from Infrastructure to APME
resolution set to Accepted
Status changed from Ready to Publish to Closed
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 03/30/2008 4:40 PM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Thanks to the authors/editors for working on this document. After a longish process, I'm happy to say it's now ready for publication as:
GFD-I.128
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 2 to 1
Status changed from Editor Review: Final to Ready to Publish
|
|
|
|
|
Reza Nejabati: 03/06/2008 3:36 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
lease find attached three files in response to review comments
1- Response to reviewers' comment
2- updated draft with changes and additional text underlined
3- updated draft with changes and additional text (not underlined)
Note (each file is in different comment )
|
| |
Attachment: |
OGF_GHPN_GOBS_final_rv1_underline.doc
(666.5 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
|
Reza Nejabati: 03/06/2008 3:35 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
lease find attached three files in response to review comments
1- Response to reviewers' comment
2- updated draft with changes and additional text underlined
3- updated draft with changes and additional text (not underlined)
|
| |
Attachment: |
OGF_GHPN_GOBS_final_rv1.doc
(666 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
|
Reza Nejabati: 03/06/2008 3:32 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
please find attached three files in response to review comments
1- Response to reviewers' comment
2- updated draft with changes and additional text underlined
3- updated draft with changes and additional text (not underlined)
|
| |
Attachment: |
Response to reviewersâ comments.doc
(31 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/22/2008 1:45 PM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
Thanks for these comments, which seem to require some response and a likely updated document.
Please provide the new document in this tracker, then set the tracker back to me and we'll move to the next steps.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Priority changed from 4 to 2
|
|
|
Reza Nejabati: 02/21/2008 6:18 PM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
External reviewer's comment was recieved from Richard Hughes-Jones.
coments are minor and as follow:
I have reviewed the document and I have the following comments:
Page 5.- Grid Job Classification: Why queuing is such an important issue? I think for some services delay is very much tolerable.
Page 5.- Perhaps a mention to mixed time-size based burstifiers would be appropriate.
Page 6.- Indent fourth paragraph
Page 7.- Mention LOBS when talking about combination of GMPLS and OBS
Page 11.- Line 4 "Thus not *only* Optical"
Page 12,. change "each class to utilized" by "each class to utilize"
Page 14.- Line 6 "provide an agreed" should be changed by "provide an agreement"
Page 15.- Paragraph 4 incomplete "resembles the..."
Page 19.- O2G resembles PATON, I think a citation would be appropriate.
Page 30.- change "very like" by "very much like"
Page 35.- Description of the transport format, first paragraph is cut.
The rest looks good to me, it is a very nice, complete and useful document.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/12/2008 9:20 PM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
Another request for status was sent to the AD.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 08/06/2007 10:31 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Response received in early July. External reviews are proceeding, and expected soon.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 07/03/2007 10:46 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
I sent a ping to Richard.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 05/03/2007 3:47 PM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Based on email, the ADs are considering the possibility
of seeking external reviews.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 04/25/2007 4:31 PM EDT
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Status changed from AD Review to Author Action Needed
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 03/20/2007 10:48 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
No public comments were received, so this will go for another 30-day round. Authors/editors, please help to gather public comments for this document.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
|
|
Reza Nejabati: 01/25/2007 9:55 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
please find attached the word version of the document with the requested changes
|
| |
Attachment: |
OGF_GHPN_GOBS_final.doc
(666 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 01/24/2007 6:51 PM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
Thanks for this submission. It will be advanced to 30-day
public comment. Please ask RG members and others
to submit public comments.
Two other items:
- We need an editable format (.doc or whatever you have)
- Please consider trimming the author list to just the single
editor. The others can remain listed in the Contributors
section. This is recommended, because anyone appearing
on the masthead is considered to be accepting permanent
personal responsibility for any future needs of the document
(answering questions, preparing revisions, defending
errors, etc.)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Assigned To changed from Franco Travostino to Joel Replogle
resolution changed from Accepted to none (no value)
Status changed from Editor Review: Initial to Public Comment Period
|
|
|
|
