[Original slightly edited.]

On 11 Jan 2005, at 20:01, Dave Berry wrote:

>> The following two statements were made (as
>> recorded in the minutes [Jan 10, 2005]):
>>
>>       - An 'ogsa service' must be one that implements the
>>         profile (or parts of the profile) in the defined
>>         manner.
>>
>> 	- Note that there is no a requirement to implement
>> 	  everything in the profile. Often the statements
>> 	  are of the in form:
>>            "if something is done it must be done this
>>            way" so if something is not implemented all
>>            the related statements do not apply.
>>
>> It's not clear from this what constraints MUST be
>> satisfied for a service to be called an "OGSA service" -
>> can the profile define a minimum set of elements that a
>> service MUST implement?
>>
>> Dave.

On 15 Jan 2005, at 07:37, Dave Snelling wrote:

> Make sure this gets set as an issue, e.g. tell
> Andreas. This is an aspect of Profile that the WS-I
> community accept as read, but that we need to spell out.
> 
> Well caught Dave.
> 
.