Mass Update

Get correct final published version at http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/gfd-i.39.pdf

Stacey, you have published the wrong document.
The 6-page introduction is just the header;

as I wrote in my previous post, the real document is:

http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/gfd-i.39.pdf

(and it is too big for upload to gridforge)

Mass Update

This document is approved for publication

Greg, I have incorporated your remarks.
The DOC file for the preface (only) is attached.

Please take the final version of the overall proceedings from

http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/gfd-i.39.pdf

Thanks.

Aha - sorry, I understand now.   Please go ahead and upload the .doc you use for the front-matter, then let us know a URL to get the final, complete 
PDF.  There are only a few small things I would like to ask:

1. Add the "39" indicator to the page header, with GFD rather than GWD (final document, versus working document):  GFD-I.39

2. In the Abstract, "papers that have been accepted" should probably be "papers that were presented", right?

3. Under section 4, you have "..." at the end of the first line.  It looks like you meant to add some other words here.

4. The intro section has page numbers in the center bottom, but the papers section has page numbers in the upper right.  Could this be made consistent
?

These are all small changes, I hope.  Thanks again for your work on this submissions!

Sorry for the trouble, Thilo.  I think the upload size limit is still in place, but here's what we'll do:

1. This document is now through the GFSG final review, and approved (by me, the editor) for publication.  

2. Please put the .doc up for download somewhere, or email it to me: 
newby AT arsc.edu

3. We'll prepare the final PDF (we like to keep the .doc too, in case of minor formatting issues in the future).

Thanks for your work on this!  It looks like a fine set of proceedings, and a worthwhile addition to the GGF document series.

Amazing how things can go wrong...
The DOC file attached is outdated and should have never been here at all. Simultaneously, I cannot find the right file (the PDF) attached here.

Again, this file is available at 
http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/ggf8-ws-apps-updt-v2.pdf

I cannot attach this file as GridForge refuses to do so (too big).

Could someone please tell me how we can finalize this issue?
Thanks!

I agree w/ Stacy.  A duplicate tracker did exist at one point
but that was removed; this is the correct tracker.

This document completed the 30d public comment period on
29 Oct 04 and got several positive comments.  The GFSG Final
Review Period technically ended on 13 Nov 04.  Hence, I think
the document is ready for publication and the ball is in the
GGF Editor's court, i.e., I'm changing the priority to 1 and the
status to "Final Editor Review".

There was discussion on the GFSG call today that Satoshi thought that this document may be a duplicate and have already been published. I do not see 
this document as one of the published documents. This document was written together with APPS-RG and UPDT-RG. Recently UPDT-RG published GFD.33 but it
 is not the same document. 

There was a duplicate tracker for this document but that tracker was closed so this is the right tracker. 

Therefore, this document is not a duplicate and should continue through the pipeline. If I am wrong please let me know.

This document has finished its 30 day public comment period. You can view comments at https://forge.gridforum.org/forum/forum.php?forum_id=437

This document will now enter a 30 day public comment period. 

Due date: 10-28-04

Thilo-

Could you send me that document thru email to me and I'll put the latest draft up in public comment? or what is your website url?

OOPS, sorry about that.
GridForge should be fixed to accomodate larger file upload.

In any case the new docment addresses all my concerns, and as such should be promptly moved to public comment as agreed upon  in the last GFSG call. 
(In fact I will do that now.)

Please do not put this version up for public comment!
Similar comments had already been raised by Craig Lee.
A while ago, I had addressed them and produced a revised version.
For a reason I don't know, that new version ended up with a new tracker item, 1092. That tracker item now is in the "trashcan" category :-(

Anyway, the document is too big for upload into gridforge.
The definite document is at:
http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/ggf8-ws-apps-updt-v2.pdf

Please use the new version for public comment!
Thanks.

This tracker item has been superceded by item 1092.
I have no idea why there is a new item at all, but still 770 could be closed.

Mass Move

Version 2 of the document addresses the comments made by AD Craig Lee.

As usual :-( 
the file is too big for upload.
Please take it from http://www.cs.vu.nl/~kielmann/ggf8-ws-apps-updt-v2.pdf

This doc is essentially the proceedings for the Grid Apps
and Programming Tools workshop at GGF8.  Comments
were sent back to the workshop organizers and GWD-I
authors to add a some analysis and insight for how well the
papers presented addressed the goals of the workshop
and what was learned.  Pending these minor revisions,
we could advance this doc in the pipeline.

PDFs seems to be the only way to produce a workshop proceedings.

The proceedings consists of 4 pages introduction which has been written in Word. (which is attached)
And these 4 pages are the ones where editing makes sense.
(The rest are the papers from the authors.)

The GGF editor could edit this Word document and send it back to Thilo if changes need to be made. Thilo can then generate a new, overall PDF file 
from the edited Word file and the individual papers.