Please disregard my earlier uploads.  This one is correct, I think.

Published as GFD-R.073.   Thanks to authors/editors
for their work on this document.

Approved for publication by the GFSG.  This will
go into final editor review to check formatting etc.

Hi Greg,

ACS-WG has finished revision of this document and ask me to bring it forward to GGF Editor. They did good job, made a final call, and answered all 
public comments in the tracker. 

As a shepherd, I would very much appreciate it if you could look at this revised document.

Authors/editors: Please review public comments, and
if necessary submit a revised document to this tracker.
Work with your area director as needed for guidance.
When you are ready to advance this document to the
next step, assign the tracker back to gbn.  Thanks!

The public comment tracker is:
https://forge.gridforum.org/forum/forum.php?forum_id=592
(also I see some comments are in this tracker)

Thanks for this submission.  It is nicely organized and
well-written.  I did not see any changes to recommend,
so am moving it into initial 15-day GFSG review prior
to 60-day public comment.

Because of holidays, it might be an extra week or more
before we get this document on the GFSG teleconference
agenda.  As long as any items raised by the GFSG are
fairly minor, we'll be able to get this into public comment
soon.

In the meantime, you might want to go ahead with addressing
Hiro Kishimoto's comments -- these could be done before
public comment, or after.

Hi Greg,

I've read this document and I believe this document is ready for GFSG review to enter public comments period. Application Contents Service is one of 
key grid services of OGSA EMS. It defines OGSA WSRF BP based archive interface and archiver descriptor format.

The following is my comments and they should be posted as public comments.

(1) The title should be ACS 1.0. Revision 1 is redundant.

(2) Since OGSA is a trademark of GGF, it should be mentioned in the first page.

(3) Policy rule (on page 4) is too generic. Should be called more
specific term.

(4) Section 1.2 need some examples which explain what are out of scope.

(5) Section title 2.1.2. I am not sure what does "Grid" mean here.

(6) Section 2.1.3 needs more explanation.

(7) Section 2.4 should read "OGSA WSRF BP" instead of "OGSA
infrastructure."

(8) Section 3.1.5. Please explain the difference between AA
Identifier and WS-Name.

(9) I think section 3.2.1 should be a part of Chapter 5.

(10) Section 3.3.4 mentions Byte-IO and GridFTP as a part
of OGSA-data WG. However, these are developed by the other
WGs.

(11) Section 3.3.5 refers OGSA WSDM profile but it is not yet
planned.

(12) Since chapter 7 is not normative, please use "must" instead
of "MUST."

(13) Schema definitions in section 9.1, 9.2 and 9.3 need GGF 
copyright statement.

(14) I prefer to separate normative reference and non-normative reference (page 74). Also OGSA WSRF BP and WSRF references are not uptodate.