|
|
|
Greg Newby: 09/11/2007 10:38 AM EDT
|
| |
Action: |
Move
Moved from Submit OGF Draft to Published
Category changed from Recommendations Track to Community Practice
Group changed from Compute to APME
resolution set to Accepted
Status changed from Ready to Publish to Closed
|
|
|
Joel Replogle: 08/28/2007 5:48 PM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Published as GFD.114 on 2007-08-28
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 08/28/2007 1:43 PM EDT
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Status changed from GFSG Review: Last call to Ready to Publish
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Chris Smith: 08/24/2007 4:58 PM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Fixed an XML tag name mismatch between HPC Basic Profile and the HPC Profile Application JSDL extension.
|
| |
Attachment: |
HPC_Basic_Profile_v1.0_final.doc
(136.5 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 08/21/2007 10:55 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Discussed on the GFSG telecon, and approved for moving to 7-day GFSG mailing list last call.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Priority changed from 2 to 1
Status changed from GFSG Review: 15-day final to GFSG Review: Last call
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 08/07/2007 6:21 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
When published, this will be GFD-R-P.114.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 05/06/2007 5:05 AM EDT
|
| |
Comment: |
Authors/editors: please review public comments
and respond in that tracker or this. If updates to the
document are needed, add them to this tracker.
When ready for the next step, indicate it here.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to Ramin Yahyapour
Priority changed from 3 to 2
Status changed from Public Comment Period to Author Action Needed
|
|
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/27/2007 11:00 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
Per GFSG conference call, coordination with BES will happen post-public comment. The GFSG confirmed this is ready for 60-day public comment.
We will copy Ramin's comments from this tracker to the PC tracker.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Assigned To changed from Ramin Yahyapour to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 4 to 3
Status changed from GFSG Review: Initial to Public Comment Period
|
|
|
Ramin Yahyapour: 02/14/2007 8:02 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
I read the latest version of the document.
Overall, the document is well written and I recommend it for publication.
Nevertheless some minor comments:
1) It should be noted for the editor that the current doc has references to OGF documents which are not yet published documents. These are at least
JSDLHPC, HPC-U, BES10.
As some of these are or will be in the editor pipeline shortly, I suggest that this doc moves forward, but an editorial update takes place prior to
publication. The reference section could be updated to include the then available GFD numbers.
As this does not change anything vital in this doc, this should not require any delay or re-opening for the public comment.
2) Section 4, page 4 has a reference to the BES UnsupportedFeatureFault. The failure model in BES is currently subject of some discussion on the BES
list. I suggest to carefully monitor this process and if necessary to consider an update this line prior to publication.
3) hyphenation of XML element names might be ambiguous and confuse some people (well not really).
However, I have no real solution how to handle this.
But looking on page 6, line 4 or line 7 and similar occurrences later, one might ask whether we could prevent some hyphenations of "bes-factory:
FactoryResourceAttributesDocument".
Especially the hyphenation at a "-" could create some ambiguity that needs re-checking with the BES spec.
(Compare to "ContainedRe-source" hyphenation later that page.) Maybe another pass with some manual editing might help to at least minimize the
hyphenation of these element names.
Otherwise the document is fine.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Stephen Pickles: 02/14/2007 6:52 AM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
I read this document while it was in working group last call. In my opinion, it is fit to go to public comment as a proposed recommendation.
Note that it references the OGSA-BES spec, which is still in working group last call.
|
| |
Action: |
Update
|
|
|
Greg Newby: 02/13/2007 2:33 PM EST
|
| |
Comment: |
Document received via email from Marty Humphrey.
I reviewed it, and am submitting for initial GFSG
15-day review.
|
| |
Attachment: |
HPC_Basic_Profile_v1.0.pdf
(228.35 KB)
|
| |
Action: |
Update
Added an attachment.
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to Ramin Yahyapour
Status changed from Public Comment Period to GFSG Review: Initial
|
|
|
|
