This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/go/artf3449?nav=1 at Thu, 03 Nov 2022 16:12:47 GMT SourceForge : artf3449: (982) Survey of IPv4 Dependencies in Global Grid Forum Specifications

Project Home

Tracker

Documents

Tasks

Source Code

Discussions

File Releases

Wiki

Project Admin
Search Tracker
Project: Editor     Trackers > Published > View Artifact
Artifact artf3449 : (982) Survey of IPv4 Dependencies in Global Grid Forum Specifications
Tracker: Published
Title: (982) Survey of IPv4 Dependencies in Global Grid Forum Specifications
Description:
This IPv6 Working Group document has passed working group last call. It has  been read by the ADs and a small number of 
other WG chairs..
Submitted By: Piers O'Hanlon
Submitted On: 07/20/2004 5:15 AM EST
Last Modified: 05/06/2007 4:46 AM EDT
Closed: 07/13/2005 1:14 AM EST

Status / Comments Change Log Associations (1) Attachments (9)  
Status  
Group: *
Status:* Closed
Category: *
Customer: *
Priority: * 0
Assigned To: * None
Reported in Release: *
Fixed in Release: *
Estimated Hours: * 0
Actual Hours: * 0
resolution: *
Comments
Greg Newby: 05/06/2007 4:46 AM EDT
  Action: Update
resolution changed from PUBLISHED to none (no value)
Greg Newby: 07/13/2005 1:14 AM EST
  Comment:
Mass Update
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Open to Closed
close_date changed from - to 2005-07-12 22:14:42
resolution changed from <None> to PUBLISHED
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 12/16/2004 1:33 PM EST
  Attachment: GFD.041.pdf (162.83 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 517: GFD.041.pdf
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 12/16/2004 1:31 PM EST
  Attachment: GFD.041.doc (205 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 516: GFD.041.doc
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 12/15/2004 1:00 PM EST
  Attachment: GFD.039.pdf (2.42 MB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 511: GFD.039.pdf
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 12/15/2004 1:00 PM EST
  Attachment: GFD.039.doc (50.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 510: GFD.039.doc
Greg Newby: 12/14/2004 9:57 PM EST
  Attachment: gfd-i.40.doc (206 KB)
  Action: Update
File Deleted changed from 497: gfd-i.40.pdf to none (no value)
File added set to 509: gfd-i.40.doc
Greg Newby: 12/14/2004 9:57 PM EST
  Attachment: gfd-i.40.doc (206 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 508: gfd-i.40.doc
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 12/01/2004 1:26 PM EST
  Comment:
Mass Move
  Action: Update
artifact_group changed from DATA to <None>
artifact_status changed from Closed to Open
assigned_to changed from 122 to 100
Category changed from Informational to <None>
group_artifact_id changed from Submit GGF Draft to Published
resolution changed from Published to <None>
Greg Newby: 11/26/2004 11:22 PM EST
  Attachment: gfd-i.40.pdf (271.67 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 498: gfd-i.40.pdf
Greg Newby: 11/26/2004 11:22 PM EST
  Comment:
I was just wondering whether the Survey (this tracker, #982) should be numbered first in the GGF document series, or the Guidelines (tracker #981).  
If you think the Guidelines should be first, let us know and we'll renumber them.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 11/26/2004 11:22 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Final Editor Review to Closed
close_date changed from - to 2004-11-26 19:22:24
Priority changed from 2 to -
resolution changed from <None> to Published
Greg Newby: 11/26/2004 11:20 PM EST
  Comment:
Thanks very much.  This looks super, and is now published as GFD #40.  Stacey will move the files to their final destination.  I appreciate your 
diligence on this document!
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 11/26/2004 11:20 PM EST
  Action: Update
File added set to 497: gfd-i.40.pdf
Rute Sofia: 11/26/2004 6:11 AM EST
  Comment:
Final revised version. Changes mentioned on tracker 982 have been made. Some comments:

- on sections 2.2.1/2.4.2:
the example for the literal IPv6 address usage has been added. However, this is a survey and as such simply alerts to the fact that a specification is
/isn't IPv6 compliant. The way that implementations should deal with such issues have already been addressed in the "Guideline for IP version 
independence in GGF specifications" draft.

- on section 7., security considerations:
Given that this is a survey on specifications,the comments made on tracker #981 for the guidelines for IP independence draft do not apply here, they 
are out of the scope of the document.
  Action: Update
Rute Sofia: 11/26/2004 6:11 AM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-ipv6-ipv4-dependencies-survey-00-rute-25-11-04.doc (215.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 496: draft-ggf-ipv6-ipv4-dependencies-survey-00-rute-25-11-04.doc
artifact_status changed from Pending Info from Authors to Final Editor Review
resolution changed from Returned to Authors/Group to <None>
Greg Newby: 11/22/2004 3:25 PM EST
  Comment:
This document is ready to go.  I'm making a few small recommendations, to accompany your "Guidelines" document (tracker 981).  Please upload a final 
document when you're ready.

- update the date in the header.

- consider whether there are really 5 Authors (for the header), or whether there are just one or two Editors and the rest are contributors (for 
listing in a later section).  It seems that sometimes people list everyone involved in a document as an Author, which is not ideal.  An Author (or 
Editor) is someone who can vouch for the entire document, and is willing to engage in correspondence & upkeep for the forseeable future.  If all 5 are
 authors, that's fine - but if not, consider listing just one or two editors, and moving the rest to a Contributor section.

- 1.2 "GRID" - is this an acronym, or just Grid?  (There is not yet a standard use of "Grid" versus "grid," but my view is that "Grid" currently means
 the (GGF) standards-compliant grid, and "grid" is generic).

- please double-check that all acronyms are written fully on first use

- 2.2.1: could you put an example of correct usage for http://example.com or similar?  Ditto for 2.4.2.

- Section 5: the 1st paragraph(s) before the table have some spacing or other issues.  It's not clear whether this is three paragraphs missing extra 
lines in-between, or whether it's supposed to be one paragraph.  Just a little formatting will fix this.

- Section 6: See my comment about security considerations for tracker 981.  Might the same apply here?  Is there a risk from improper specification of
 use of IP versions?

- References: add a blank line after each reference, or outdent each entry.

Go ahead and respond or update, and upload the final version.  Thanks for your work on this!
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 11/22/2004 3:25 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Final Editor Review to Pending Info from Authors
assigned_to changed from 302 to 122
Priority changed from 1 to 2
resolution changed from <None> to Returned to Authors/Group
Greg Newby: 11/04/2004 7:58 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Pending Info from Authors to Final Editor Review
assigned_to changed from 122 to 302
Priority changed from 4 to 1
resolution changed from Returned to Authors/Group to <None>
Greg Newby: 11/02/2004 1:11 PM EST
  Comment:
gbn: Sent email to Piers O'Hanlon requesting his feedback on the effectiveness of public comment for this and associated document #981.  Status 
changed to Awaiting Author Feedback.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 11/02/2004 1:11 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Public Comment Period to Pending Info from Authors
Priority changed from 3 to 4
resolution changed from <None> to Returned to Authors/Group
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 09/28/2004 3:43 PM EST
  Comment:
No comments have been made regarding this document so it will re-enter public comment period again.

Due date: 10-28-04.
  Action: Update
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 08/13/2004 10:46 AM EST
  Comment:
Document will now enter 30 day public comment period.

Due date: 9-13-04
  Action: Update
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 08/13/2004 10:46 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from GFSG Review to Public Comment Period
Charlie Catlett: 08/12/2004 4:21 PM EST
  Comment:
This draft has completed the necessary steps prior to
being made available for public comment.  Authors, 
working group / research group chairs, and Area
Directors should encourage individuals to participate
in the public comment process and should announce
the public comment availability to appropriate
communities and groups.

Public comments can be viewed and submitted via
the GridForge Editor pages (see Forums) or:

http://www.ggf.org/documents

Public comments play an important part in the advancement
of a GGF draft and publication as a document in the 
GGF document series.

An active public comment period strengthens the case
that the document is a useful and desired work product
for some community of consumers.
  Action: Update
Charlie Catlett: 08/12/2004 4:21 PM EST
  Action: Update
Priority changed from 4 to 3
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 08/11/2004 10:41 AM EST
  Comment:
Mass Update
  Action: Update
assigned_to changed from 278 to 122
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 07/22/2004 11:43 AM EST
  Comment:
Mass Update
  Action: Update
Priority changed from 5 to 4
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 07/22/2004 11:42 AM EST
  Comment:
This document has already been reviewed by an AD. It will now proceed to GFSG Review.
  Action: Update
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 07/22/2004 11:42 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from AD Review to GFSG Review
Stacey Giannese(disabled): 07/21/2004 12:53 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Open to AD Review
assigned_to changed from 108 to 278
Priority changed from - to 5
Piers O'Hanlon: 07/20/2004 5:15 AM EST
  Action: Create

Piers O'Hanlon: 07/20/2004 5:15 AM EST
  Attachment: draft-ggf-ipv6-ipv4-dependencies-survey-00_3004-brian-14-7-04.doc (188.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 383: draft-ggf-ipv6-ipv4-dependencies-survey-00_3004-brian-14-7-04.doc

 
 
 
< Previous
 
 
Next >
 


The Open Grid Forum Contact Webmaster | Report a problem | GridForge Help
This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/go/artf3449?nav=1 at Thu, 03 Nov 2022 16:13:01 GMT