This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/go/artf3388?nav=1 at Thu, 03 Nov 2022 16:06:34 GMT SourceForge : artf3388: (1617) WS-AgreementSpecification

Project Home

Tracker

Documents

Tasks

Source Code

Discussions

File Releases

Wiki

Project Admin
Search Tracker
Project: Editor     Trackers > Published > View Artifact
Artifact artf3388 : (1617) WS-AgreementSpecification
Tracker: Published
Title: (1617) WS-AgreementSpecification
Description:
Submission of WS-Agreement specification by GRAAP-WG.  This is the second submission following the public comment period
 in early 2005..
Submitted By: Jim Pruyne
Submitted On: 09/20/2005 6:45 PM EST
Last Modified: 07/03/2007 11:24 AM EDT
Closed: 07/03/2007 10:59 AM EDT

Status / Comments Change Log Associations Attachments (7)  
Status  
Group: * APME
Status:* Closed
Category: * Community Practice
Customer: *
Priority: * 0
Assigned To: * None
Reported in Release: *
Fixed in Release: *
Estimated Hours: * 0
Actual Hours: * 0
resolution: * Accepted
Comments
Greg Newby: 07/03/2007 11:24 AM EDT
  Action: Move
Moved from Submit OGF Draft to Published
Category changed from Recommendations Track to Community Practice
Group changed from Compute to APME
resolution set to Accepted
Greg Newby: 07/03/2007 10:59 AM EDT
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to none (no value)
Closed set to 07/03/2007
Priority changed from 1 to 0
Status changed from Ready to Publish to Closed
Greg Newby: 05/22/2007 10:24 AM EDT
  Comment:
This will now be published as GFD-R-P.107.
Thanks to the authors/editors for their
efforts for this document!
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Greg Newby to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 2 to 1
Status changed from GFSG Review: 15-day final to Ready to Publish
Greg Newby: 05/06/2007 6:40 AM EDT
  Comment:
This document is now in 7-day GFSG mailing list final call.
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Stephen Pickles to Greg Newby
Greg Newby: 05/01/2007 10:21 AM EDT
  Comment:
The standards council deliberation is delayed until May 6.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 04/24/2007 11:54 AM EDT
  Comment:
Per the April 24 standards council call, this document will go before the standards council on May 1 instead.  Then, the assembled GFSG will decide on
 it at the OGF20 f2f (May 6).  This  is just to move things along a little faster, due to OGF20.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 04/20/2007 2:47 PM EDT
  Comment:
Sorry for missing this document's updated status.
It's now scheduled for the GFSG standards council
telecon on May 8 or as soon thereafter as may be.
  Action: Update
Stephen Pickles: 04/06/2007 12:10 PM EDT
  Comment:
The attached version corrects a naming inconsistency between document text and schema. The inconsistency was noticed and fixed by the document authors
 after the document entered final GFSG review. The review continues using the corrected version. The provenance of the correction can be traced on the
 GRAAP-WG mailing list.
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraft-finalfinal-2.doc (699.5 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Stephen Pickles: 04/03/2007 8:00 AM EDT
  Comment:
This document is now in GFSG final review.
  Action: Update
Status changed from Author Action Needed to GFSG Review: 15-day final
Ramin Yahyapour: 03/29/2007 3:17 PM EDT
  Comment:
The authors updated the document after public comment period. 
The document was in last call on the mailing list.
Document is now ready for final review.
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraft-finalfinal.doc (732.5 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Greg Newby: 03/20/2007 11:52 AM EDT
  Comment:
Sent a ping to the author.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 12/08/2006 3:21 AM EST
  Comment:
Authors/editors: Please review the public comments.  If needed, upload another new document for final review.  
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Joel Replogle to Stephen Pickles
Priority changed from 3 to 2
Status changed from Public Comment Period to Returned to Author(s)
Greg Newby: 11/11/2006 7:17 PM EST
  Comment:
The public comment tracker is here:
 https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/discussion/do/listTopics/projects.ggf-editor/discussion.rec_ws_agreement_spec_0
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 10/26/2006 8:08 PM EDT
  Comment:
Changes were sent via email; they are attached here.
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraftFinal+sp+tn+jpver.doc (815 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Greg Newby: 10/24/2006 10:37 AM EDT
  Comment:
The note below was received on 27 Sep.  We still need to see the list of changes (these could be posted into the public comment tracker). 

This will now go to *30* day public comment, per the GFSG.

"Greg,

We discussed this on our call today.  The downside for us, of course, is
that it delays finalizing this version, and we've done public comment
twice before.  We also have implementers who are keen to proceed with a
stable version.  On the upside, it would be great to get wider
distribution, and if that can get it past people in OASIS and even OGSA.
that would be great.  So, with some reluctance, though also with
understanding of GFSG's position, we're willing to go ahead with this.

To get to the point of opening to comments again, I've started from
Stephen's version which corrected some typos, formatting, etc., and I've
removed the splash page.  I think I have the simple copyright statement
in place, but I have not yet found an example doc. that has the update
IP statement.  If you could provide that, that would be helpful.  We're
also preparing a summary of changes.  This will be based on our internal
comment management spreadsheet and what's been presented at previous GGF
meetings.  Hopefully, that can be ready within a week or so.

With all of these completed, we can do another public comment.  I think
the document only lacks the IP statement at this point.

--- Jim"
  Action: Update
Assigned To changed from Stephen Pickles to Joel Replogle
Priority changed from 2 to 3
Status changed from Returned to Author(s) to Public Comment Period
Jim Pruyne: 09/27/2006 11:17 AM EDT
  Comment:
Thanks, Stephen.  We'll continue from this version on any further work.
  Action: Update
Stephen Pickles: 09/27/2006 11:05 AM EDT
  Comment:
I have attached a version which fixes a few typos, and makes some formatting more consistent. This version contains no substantive changes to the spec
, normative or otherwise.
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraftFinal+sp.doc (775 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Greg Newby: 09/26/2006 11:06 AM EDT
  Comment:
The GFSG discussed this document during the September 26
conference call.  Based on the extent of public comments,
the GFSG would like to recommend a further public comment
period.  Because it has already been through 60-day comment,
we are suggesting a 30-day public comment period.

Further details sent to Jim. We'll wait to hear back before moving to the next step.
  Action: Update
Status changed from Final 15day GFSG Review to Returned to Author(s)
None: 09/26/2006 10:32 AM EDT
  Comment:
Note that the public comment tracker is here (relocated):  https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/discussion/do/listTopics/projects.ggf-editor/discussion.
rec_ws_agreement_spec_1
  Action: Update
Jim Pruyne: 09/08/2006 1:37 AM EDT
  Comment:
And now, without further ado, the editable version...
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraftFinal.doc (797.5 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Greg Newby: 09/07/2006 2:08 PM EDT
  Comment:
Note that we need an editable file for this document.

Meanwhile, I'll schedule it for GFSG final review, for discussion during the September 26 conference call, or as soon thereafter as is available.

  Action: Update
Status changed from Returned to Author(s) to Final 15day GFSG Review
Jim Pruyne: 09/07/2006 5:24 AM EDT
  Comment:
Attached is the proposed final version.  All comments from public comment period have been addressed.  The WG feels that this version is complete, and
 ready for publication.
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraft20060907.pdf (427.13 KB)
  Action: Update
Added an attachment.
Greg Newby: 09/03/2006 7:56 PM EDT
  Comment:
Sent a ping to the submitter.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 03/26/2006 9:02 PM EST
  Comment:
Sent a ping to the author.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 01/09/2006 5:25 PM EST
  Comment:
Authors, please review public comments here:
https://forge.gridforum.org/forum/forum.php?forum_id=577

Either respond in that tracker, or this one.  Perhaps
you will make a further iteration of the document.

When you are done responding to comments, please
indicate so in this tracker, and we will move this
to the GFSG review stage.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 01/09/2006 5:25 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Public Comment Period to Returned to Author(s)
assigned_to changed from 9357 to 229
Priority changed from 3 to 2
Stephen Pickles: 10/19/2005 2:14 AM EST
  Comment:
I've read this document carefully and support its transition to public comment period.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 10/18/2005 10:16 AM EST
  Comment:
This document is now in 60-day public comment,
and will be due 60 days from public announcement.

The GFSG had some discussion echoing the other
comments in the tracker about the scope and
specificity of this document.  It seems that further
specs will be required for this spec to be fully
useful, but as a long document already the current
document seems to strike a good balance.  Thus,
the GFSG didn't recommend any specific changes
before public comment.  (These are my notes from
the discussion, so I hope I remember the 
sentiments correctly.)
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 10/18/2005 10:16 AM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from GFSG Review to Public Comment Period
assigned_to changed from 229 to 9357
Priority changed from 4 to 3
Geoffrey Fox: 10/05/2005 10:18 PM EST
  Comment:
I suggest this standard be named either
GS-Agreement or
GGF-Agreement
GGF desperately needs a clearer branding and our incoherent
labelling does not help
e.g. we have
GridFTP
DFDL
WS-Agreement
Info-D
OGSA-DAI
They should be clearly associated from name with GGF

I understand that WS-Agreement is not Grid specific; it is however GGF specific
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 10/02/2005 3:00 PM EST
  Action: Update
assigned_to changed from 133 to 229
David Snelling: 09/29/2005 10:43 AM EST
  Comment:
Jim,

All of the following have later versions:

wsa	http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/ws/2004/03/addressing  
wsbf	http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/stdwip/web-services/WS-BaseFaults
wssg	http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/stdwip/web-services/WS-ServiceGroup  
wsrp	http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/stdwip/web-services/WS-ResourceProperties  

Addressing and the WSRF suite should be full standards by the end of the year. You should plan on two steps:

1) Check the current latest versions to make sure that there are no significant semantic changes in them that interfere with your spec. my guess is 
that you will be OK here.

2) Undertake to move to these specifications as soon as possibly, but preferably before going for proposaed recommendation.
  Action: Update
Jim Pruyne: 09/28/2005 10:52 AM EST
  Comment:
Dave,

Could you perhaps be a little more specific on the dependent specifications that are out-of-date.  Our intent would certainly be to stay current.

Thanks.
  Action: Update
David Snelling: 09/27/2005 9:18 AM EST
  Comment:
Probably OK for public Comment. 

It is still a very complex specification and I have concerns about multiple implementations being created of it in its current form. This is 
particularly the case, as it is built on out dated versions of all its dependent specifications. I would recommend that the authors commit (if they 
have not already done so) to moving to the stable specifications when they become available.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/25/2005 4:32 PM EST
  Comment:
This document is now in 15-day GFSG review prior
to public comment.  Because of the GGF15 conference next
week, I'm allowing an extra week: GFSG review
due October 18 or as soon thereafter as possible.

I uploaded a document with "accept changes" for the GFSG
review.  The only minor formatting issue is moving the
full copyright/IP statements (without the GGF logo) to the
end of the document.  This can be accomplished by the authors
before the next phase of the review, along with anything
else the GFSG identifies.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/25/2005 4:32 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Initial Editor Review to GFSG Review
assigned_to changed from 302 to 133
Priority changed from 5 to 4
resolution changed from Accepted to <None>
Greg Newby: 09/22/2005 1:59 AM EST
  Comment:
Note that a substantially different earlier version
went through public comment, then was withdrawn
temporarily:
  https://forge.gridforum.org/tracker/?aid=1062

This document will go into GFSG 15-day review, 
prior to public comment.
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/20/2005 6:57 PM EST
  Comment:
Dear Author or Draft Editor-

Thank you for submitting your draft to the GGF Editor!  In most cases the draft 
will be assigned to an Area Director for review as the first step in the document 
publication process.

The URL provided with this note allows you to track your submission and to 
communicate with the GGF Editor or Area Director(s) who are reviewing the 
draft.  At the very bottom of the tracker display (web page) a detailed log of all 
actions related to this submission is available.

You may also wish to alert your colleagues that the draft has been submitted, and from their GridForge accounts they may wish to monitor this item in 
order to receive email any time action is taken regarding this submission.

Informational and Experimental drafts are reviewed by the GGF Editor and one 
or more Area Directors.  The GGF Editor will determine whether the draft is 
ready for public comment, or if there are items for the author(s) to address 
prior to public comment.  This initial review generally takes no more than two 
weeks.

Community Practice and Recommendations Track drafts require a GFSG review 
prior to public comment.  This can add 2-3 weeks to the initial GGF Editor 
review depending on current workload of the GFSG.

Please do not hesitate to inquire about the status of your submission at any time by way of comments added to this tracker item, which will be 
automatically emailed to the individual who appears in the "assigned to" field.

Thanks very much- 
GGF Editor
  Action: Update
Greg Newby: 09/20/2005 6:57 PM EST
  Action: Update
artifact_status changed from Open to Initial Editor Review
Priority changed from - to 5
resolution changed from <None> to Accepted
Jim Pruyne: 09/20/2005 6:45 PM EST
  Action: Create

Jim Pruyne: 09/20/2005 6:45 PM EST
  Attachment: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraft050920.doc (773.5 KB)
  Action: Update
File added set to 682: WS-AgreementSpecificationDraft050920.doc

 
 
 
< Previous
 
 
Next >
 


The Open Grid Forum Contact Webmaster | Report a problem | GridForge Help
This is a static archive of the previous Open Grid Forum GridForge content management system saved from host forge.ogf.org file /sf/go/artf3388?nav=1 at Thu, 03 Nov 2022 16:06:45 GMT